![]() |
|
Antidepressants have a well-established role in the treatment of bipolar disorder (BD). There is also a known, inherent risk of antidepressant-induced mania in bipolar illness (as high as 35% [1]) that is accepted and considered in any treatment decision. However, a paradoxical shift to mania upon withdrawal of an antidepressant is not a commonly reported occurrence. Since 1981, there have been only 17 reports of antidepressant withdrawal–induced mania in patients with unipolar depression. Most cases involved the use of tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs). There were no such case reports in patients with BD until 1998, when 2 articles were published reporting similar observations in 18 patients. Most of these cases involved the use of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs). Since 1999, there have been no other reported cases to support withdrawal mania in patients with BD. We present a review of the literature and provide a supporting case report of a patient with BD who had a clear manic episode precipitated by abrupt discontinuation of nortriptyline. It is our hope that, as further cases are identified and reported, the sample size will become large enough for meaningful interpretations of apparent risk factors and correlative factors, such as antidepressant class or possible predisposition according to sex. MethodWe undertook a literature review through the PubMed index, using the key words mania, antidepressant withdrawal, and antidepressants in bipolar disorder. Identified articles were reviewed, and demographic data were pooled and tabulated for unipolar depression and BD. Recorded parameters were as follows: patient diagnosis; age; sex; antidepressant type, antidepressant dosage, and length of treatment before withdrawal; abrupt (< 5 days) vs gradual (5 days to 8 weeks) antidepressant discontinuation; onset of manic symptoms from time of antidepressant withdrawal; management of manic symptoms; thyroid status; and family history of BD. Means were calculated for each parameter unless data were unavailable, in which case ranges were recorded. Using the same key words, we searched related articles for possible explanations. Each theory was explained mechanistically and assessed for strengths and limitations. Literature Review ResultsFor patients with unipolar depression, we found 17 reported cases of mania induced by antidepressant withdrawal (2–10), 12 of which involved female patients. In 1 case, sex and age were not mentioned. Eliminating this study gave an age range of 21 to 65 years (mean 39 years) for female subjects and an age range of 18 to 50 years (mean 31.3 years) for male subjects. TCAs were implicated in 12 cases. Specifically, these included amitryptiline in 5 cases; imipramine in 2 cases; desipramine in 2 cases; and nortriptyline, protryptaline, and doxepin in 1 case each. Monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs) (specifically, isocarboxazid) were implicated in 2 of the 17 cases. Of the remaining cases, 1 each involved trazodone, paroxetine, and mirtazapine. Because specific data were unavailable in some studies, it was difficult to calculate a true mean length of treatment. We therefore divided treatment length into 2 categories: # 6 weeks and > 6 weeks, since antidepressant-induced mania is known to occur in the same time period that it takes for an antidepressant to have an effect (that is, 4 to 6 weeks). In 4/17 cases, antidepressant treatment was for 6 weeks or less, and in 13/17 cases treatment was for more than 6 weeks, with a range of 9 weeks to 19 years. Withdrawal was abrupt in 8/17 cases and gradual in 9/17. The average time to onset of manic symptoms was 3.9 days, with a single outlier occurring 7 weeks after abrupt discontinuation of doxepin 25 mg 3 times daily that had been taken for 19 years. Symptoms were managed by reinstituting the anti- depressant in 3/17 cases (specifically, desipramine in 2 cases and doxepin in 1 case), by starting antipsychotics in 3/17 cases, by starting antipsychotics and lithium in 2/17 cases, and by starting lithium alone in 1 of 17 case. Symptoms resolved spontaneously in 2/17 cases. Of the remaining cases, 3 refused treatment, symptom management was not reported in 2, and no treatment was necessary in 1 case. Family history was negative in 11/17 cases, positive in 2/17 cases, and not mentioned in 4/17 cases. For patients with BD, a study by Goldstein and colleagues described 6 cases of antidepressant withdrawal–induced mania (11). Data on age and sex were not provided. SSRIs were implicated in 3/6 cases (specifically, sertraline in 2 cases and fluoxetine in 1 case). TCAs were implicated in 2/6 cases (specifically, 1 case each involving desipramine and nortyrptiline). The last case implicated venlafaxine. Treatment length was 35 to 480 days, with a mean of 203 days (6.5 months). In 1 of the 6 cases, the treatment length was only 5 weeks, and the antidepressant was abruptly withdrawn in a single day. Withdrawal was gradual in the remaining 5 cases, with a mean taper length of 23.4 days and a range of 11 to 43 days. The average time to onset of manic symptoms was 13.5 days, with a range of 1 to 23 days. Symptoms were managed by antidepressant reinstitution in 1 case and by starting antipsychotics in 4 cases. In 1 case, symptoms were untreated. No information regarding family history of BD or thyroid status was provided in any of the 6 cases. Goldstein and colleagues refer to a finding by Shriver and others, who reported 12 such cases in a retrospective review presented at the 151st Annual APA meeting. However, apart from naming the classes of antidepressants implicated, they provide no further data from this report. Our own case example (12) involved a 74-year-old man with a 30-year history of BD who had been on nortriptyline 100 mg daily for over 12 months. He abruptly stopped taking it and developed mania symptoms within 2 days. His symptoms were successfully treated with valproic acid 500 mg twice daily and risperidone 1.5 mg twice daily. He was known to be euthryoid, and his only psychiatric family history was that his mother suffered from depression. When combined, the findings reported by Goldstein and colleagues (including those cited for Shriver and others) (11) and our own case report (12) yield the following data for implicated antidepressants: SSRIs in 10/19 cases, TCAs in 4/19 cases, MAOIs in 3/19 cases, and SNRIs in 2/19 cases. Goldstein and colleagues considered several differential diagnoses to explain this phenomenon, including anti- depressant-induced mania leading to antidepressant discontinuation, agitated depression, physiological withdrawal syndrome, and spontaneous mania as the natural course of the illness (11). When these potential confounders were evaluated, however, they were ruled out as differential diagnostic considerations. Mania associated with antidepressant withdrawal differs in several aspects from spontaneous mania or from antidepressant-induced mania. Table 1 provides some distinguishing features of each mania type, as observed by the reviewed reports; it may aid in identifying more cases.
DiscussionOur case example illustrates and supports the previous observations of a similar phenomenon in patients with BD. Further, when the pooled demographic data provided in Tables 2 and 3 are examined, it is interesting to note certain trends. For example, among patients with unipolar depression, mania induced by antidepressant withdrawal appears to occur more frequently with TCAs. Among patients with BD, however, it appears more frequently with the SSRIs. In addition, antidepressant withdrawal–induced mania seems to occur more frequently in female patients with unipolar depression than it does in male patients. (Unfortunately, information on sex was not available for the study population with BD.) These findings are interesting, but thus far anecdotal. They may provoke some questions regarding the establishment of possible risk factors for developing this condition when enough reported cases exist for a sufficiently large sample size. Several hypotheses have been postulated to explain the pathophysiology of antidepressant withdrawal–induced mania. They include a cholinergic–monoaminergic interaction hypothesis (13,14), hyposerotonergic mania (15), noradrenergic hyperactivity (2,10,16), rapid eye movement (REM) sleep rebound (4,17–19), and hyperdopaminergic mania (9). The Cholinergic–Monoaminergic Interaction Hypothesis
Hyposerotonergic Mania Noradrenergic Hyperactivity
Rapid Eye Movement (REM) Sleep Rebound Hyperdopaminergic Mania ConclusionsAntidepressant withdrawal–induced mania is an interesting phenomenon distinct from antidepressant-induced mania or physiological drug withdrawal. It does not appear to coincide with the natural course of BD. Withdrawal-induced cholinergic overdrive and the action of the cholinergic–noradrenergic system remains the most investigated hypothesis for explaining antidepressant withdrawal–induced mania. In summary, this hypothesis proposes that, upon cholinergic overdrive, the monoaminergic synthetic pathways are activated in an effort to maintain homeostatic balance. Once the cholinergic overdrive abates, the monoaminergic system usually downregulates in parallel. In some patients, the system fails to downregulate, leading to a state of relative monoaminergic excess and associated hypomania or mania. However, this hypothesis is limited by its inability to explain similar observations involving anti- depressants with weaker anticholinergic activity. If there were a way of predicting with some certainty which patients might be at risk for mania induced by antidepressant withdrawl, we could potentially prevent it. For example, it was interesting to note the higher proportion of patients on TCAs and of female patients affected. Its occurrence implies a higher incidence of diagnosing BD and, therefore, of treatment with mood stabilizers. With increasing reports of this phenomenon, it may be possible to develop its relation to some of the reported parameters. There is a strong suggestion that the constant switching of antidepressants in patients (iatrogenesis) may induce rapid cycling in the population with BD. This leads to several questions regarding the population with unipolar depression. After observing an episode of withdrawal mania in a patient previously diagnosed with unipolar depression, one wonders whether the diagnosis should be changed to BD, what would be the risk of another manic episode, and what may be the treatment implications for mood stabilizers. In addition, the question arises of whether reinstituting the antidepressant is sufficient treatment. Long-term follow-up studies investigating the stability of the diagnosis over time are required to answer many of these questions. Depending on the results of such studies, iatrogenesis may become a new inclusion as an etiological factor in BD. References1. Altshuler LL, Post RM, Leverich GS, Mikalauskas K, Rosoff A, Ackerman L. Antidepressant-induced mania and cycle acceleration: a controversy revisited. Am J Psychiatry 1995;152:1130–8. 2. Mirin SM, Schatzberg AF, Creasey DE. Hypomania and mania after withdrawal of tricyclic antidepressants. Am J Psychiatry 1981;138:87–9. 3. Ghadirian AM. Paradoxical mood response following antidepressant withdrawal. Biol Psychiatry 1986;21:1298–300. 4. McGrath PJ, Stewart JW, Nunes EN, Quitkin, FM, Tricamo E.. Paradoxical mood shifts to euthymia or hypomania upon withdrawal of antidepressant agents. J Clin Psychopharmacol June 1993;13:224–5. 5. Theilman SB, Christenbury MM. Hypomania following withdrawal of trazodone. Am J Psychiatry 1986;143:1482–3. 6. Callender J, MacCall C. Mirtazapine withdrawal causing hypomania. Br J Psychiatry 1999;175:390. 7. Landry P, Roy L. Withdrawal hypomania associated with paroxetine. J Clin Psychopharmacol 1997;17(1):60–1. 8. Galynker II, Rosenthal RN, Perkel C, Schwartz A.. Doxepin withdrawal mania. J Clin Psychiatry 1995;56:122–3. 9. Rothschild AJ. Mania after withdrawal of isocarboxazid. J Clin Psychopharmacol 1985;5:340–2. 10. Nelson JL, Schottenfeld RS, Conrad CD. Hypomania after desipramine withdrawal. Am J Psychiatry 1983;140:624–5. 11. Goldstein TR, Frye MA, Denicoff KD, Smith-Jackson E, Leverich GS, Bryan AL, and others. Antidepressant discontinuation-related mania: critical prospective observation and theoretical implications in bipolar disorder. J Clin Psychiatry 1999;60:563–7. 12. Ali S, Milev R. Switch to mania upon discontinuation of long term anti- depressants in patients with mood disorders: a case report. Presented as a poster at the 15th ECNP Congress; October 2002; Barcelona. 13. Dilsaver SC, Kronfol Z, Sackellares JC. Antidepressant withdrawal syndromes: evidence supporting the cholinergic overdrive hypothesis. J Clin Psychopharmacol 1983;3:157–64. 14. Dilsaver SC, Greden JF. Antidepressant withdrawal-induced activation (hypomania and mania): mechanism and theoretical significance. Brain Res Brain Res Reviews 1984;7:29–48. 15. Zajecka J, Tracy KA, Mitchell S. Discontinuation symptoms after treatment with serotonin reuptake inhibitors: a literature review. J Clin Psychiatry 1997;58:291–7. 16. Charney DS, Heninger GR, Sternberg DE, Landish H. Abrupt discontinuation of tricyclic antidepressant drugs: evidence for noradrenergic hyperactivity. Br J Psychiatry 1982;141:377–86. 17. Wehr TA, Sack DA, Rosenthal NE. Sleep reduction as a final common pathway in the genesis of mania. Am J Psychiatry 1987;144:201–4. 18. Wehr TA. The effects of sleep and wakefulness in the genesis of depression and mania. Encephale 1992;18 Spec(1):45–50. 19. Leibenluft E, Wehr TA. Is sleep deprivation useful in the treatment of depression? Am J Psychiatry 1992;149:159–68. 20. Bradley PB, Elkes J. The effect of atropine, hyoscyamine, physostigmine and neostigmine on the electrical activity of the brain of a conscious cat. J Physiol (Lon) 1953;120:14–5. 21. Bradley PB, Key BH. The effect of drugs on arousal responses produced by electrical stimulation of the reticular formation of the brain. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 1958;10:97–110. 22. Wada JA, Ikeda H. Effect of atropine and eserine on the episodic behavioral and electrographic manifestations induced by methionine sulfoximine. Exp Neurol 1996;16:450–63. 23. Darrow CW, McCulloch WS, Green JR, Davis EW,Garol HW. Parasympathetic regulation of high potential in the electroencephalogram. Arch Neurol Psychiat 1944;52:337–8. 24. Feldman SM, Waller HJ. Dissociation of electrocortical activation and behavioral arousal. Nature (Lond) 1962;196:1320–1. 25. Longo VG, Silvestrini B. Action of eserine and amphetamine on the electrical activity of the rabbit brain. J Pharmacol Exp Ther 1957;120:160–70. 26. Longo VG. Effects of scopolamine and atropine on electroencephalographic and behavioral reactions due to hypothalamic stimulation. J Pharmacol Exp Ther 1958;198–208. 27. Longo VG. Behavioral and electroencephalographic effects of atropine and related compounds. Pharmacol Rev 1965;965–96. 28. Longoni R, Mulas A, Novak BO, Pepeu IM, Pepeu G. Effect of single and repeated electroshock applications on brain acetylcholine levels and choline acetyltransferase activity in the rat. Neuropharmacology 1976;15:283–6. 29. Myers B, Roberts KH, Riciputi RH, Domino E. Some effects of muscarinic cholinergic blocking drugs on behavior and the electrocorticogram. Psychopharmacology 1964;5:289–300. 30. Miller RF. The local action of eserine on the central nervous system. J Physiol 1937;212–21. 31. Miller RF, Stavraky GW, Woonton GA. Effects of eserine, acetylcholine and atropine on the electrocorticogram. J Neurophysiol 1946;3:131–8. 32. Orkin LR, Bergman PS, Nathanson M. Effects of atropine, scopolamine and merperidine on man. Anesthesiology 1956;17:30–7. 33. Osteid AM, Aruguete A. Central nervous system effects of hyoscine in man. J Pharm Exp Ther 1962;137:697–703. 34. Szerb JC. The effect of tertiary and quarternary atropine on cortical acetylcholine output and on the electroencephalogram in cats. Can J Physiol Pharmacol 1964;42:303–14. 35. Wangeman CP, Hawk MH. The effects of morphine, atropine and scopolamine on human subjects. Anesthesiology 1942;3:24–36. 36. White RP, Rinaldi R, Himwich HE. Central and peripheral nervous system effects of atropine sulfate and mepiperphenidol bromide (darstine) on human subjects. J Appl Physiol 1956;8:635–42. 37. Wikler A. Pharmacologic dissociation of behavior and EEG ‘sleep patterns’ in dogs: morphine, N-allylnomorphine, and atropine. Society of Experimental Biological Medicine 1952;79:261–5. 38. Wilson WP, Hughes JL. Observation on the effects of JB-329 (Ditran) on the electroencephalogram of man. J Neuropsychiatry 1962;3:310–5. 39. Jasper HH, Tessier J. Acetylcholine liberation from cerebral cortex during paradoxical (REM) sleep. Science 1971;172:601–2. 40. Serra G, Argiolas A, Klimek V, Fadda F, Gessa GL. Chronic treatment with antidepressants prevents the inhibitory effect of small doses of apomorphine on dopamine synthesis and motor activity. Life Sci 1979;25:415–24. 41. Antelman SM, Chiodo LA. Dopamine autoreceptor subsensitivity; a mechanism common to the treatment of depression and the induction of amphetamine psychosis? Biol Psychiatry 1981;16:717–27. 42. Bunney WE Jr. Psychopharmacology of the switch process in affective illness. In: Killam K, DiMascio A, Lipton M, editors. Psychopharmacology: a generation of progress. New York: Raven Press; 1978. 43. Van Scheyen JD, van Kammen DP. Clomipramine-induced mania in unipolar depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1979;36:560–5. 44. Stoll A, Mayer PV, Kolbrener M, Goldstein E, Suplit B, Lucier J, and others. Antidepressant-associated mania: a controlled comparison with spontaneous mania. Am J Psychiatry 1994;151:1642–5. 45. Haddard P, Lejoyeux M, Young A. Antidepressant discontinuation reactions (are preventable and simple to treat). BMJ 1998;316:1105–6. 46. Coupland NJ, Bell CJ, Potokar JP. Serotonin reuptake inhibitor withdrawal. J Clin Psychopharmacol 1996;16:356–62. 47. Price JS, Waller PC, Wood SM, MacKay AV. A comparison of the post- marketing safety of 4 selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitors, including the investigation of symptoms occurring on withdrawal. Br J Clin Pharmacol 1996;42:757–63. Author(s)Manuscript received July 2002 and accepted September 2002. 1Psychiatry Resident, Queen’s University, Kingston, Ontario. 2Clinical Director, Mood Disorders Service, Providence Continuing Care Centre-Mental Health Services (PCCC-MHS), Kingston, Ontario. Address for correspondence: Dr S Ali, 1109 Hudson Drive, Kingston, ON K7M 5L4 e-mail: shereseali@hotmail.com
1 | 2
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||