Canadian Psychiatric Association

Editorial Credits/ Crédits éditorials

Subscription Rates /Prix d'abonnements

Advertising Rates / Tarifs publicitaires (PDF)

Editorial
Geriatric Psychiatry: Complex Challenges, Promising Treatments
Kenneth I Shulman
(PDF)

In Review
Cognitive Pharmacotherapy of Alzheimer’s Disease and Other Dementias
Nathan Herrmann

(PDF)

Brief Screening Tests for Dementia
Wendy J Lorentz, James M Scanlan, Soo Borson

(PDF)

Effective Use of Electroconvulsive Therapy in Late-Life Depression
Alastair J Flint, Nadine Gagnon

(PDF)

Review Papers
Are Leptin and Cytokines Involved in Body Weight Gain During Treatment With Antipsychotic Drugs?

Trino Baptista, Serge Beaulieu

(PDF)

Original Research
Strategies of Collaboration Between General Practitioners and Psychiatrists: A Survey of Practitioners’ Opinions and Characteristics

Ricardo J M Lucena, Alain Lesage, Robert Élie, Yves Lamontagne, Marc Corbière

(PDF)

A Test of the Phase Model of Psychotherapy Change
Anthony S Joyce, John Ogrodniczuk, William E Piper, Mary McCallum

(PDF)

Brief Communication
Lamotrigine Use in Geriatric Patients With Bipolar Depression

Matthew Robillard, David K Conn

(PDF)

Dissolution Profile, Tolerability, and Acceptability of the Orally Disintegrating Olanzapine Tablet in Patients With Schizophrenia
Pierre Chue, Barry Jones, Cindy C Taylor, Ruth Dickson

(PDF)

Progress Against Major Depression in Canada
Scott B Patten MD

(PDF)


Book Reviews
(PDF)

Obsessive–Compulsive Disorder: A Practical Guide
Reviewed by
Arun V. Ravindran

We Fly, We Cry: Our Lives With Manic Depression
Reviewed by
Paul Grof

Geriatric Consultation Liaison Psychiatry
Reviewed by
Ron Keren

Psychotherapy With Children and Adolescents
Reviewed by
Allan Frankland

The Early Stages of Schizophrenia
Reviewed by
Mary V. Seeman



Letters to the Editor
(PDF)

Re: Atypical Antipsychotic Use in Treating Adolescents and Young Adults With Developmental Disabilities

Reply: Atypical Antipsychotic Use in Treating Adolescents and Young Adults With Developmental Disabilities

Evidence Supports Validity of Seasonal Affective Disorder

Reply: Evidence Supports Validity of Seasonal Affective Disorder

Seasonal Affective Disorder: The Latitude Hypothesis Revisited

Treatment Of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder With Tiagabine

Assessing Pain Tolerance in a Patient With Acute Psychosis

Musical Hallucinations During a Treatment With Benzodiazepine

Bupropion-Methylphenidate Combination and Grand Mal Seizures

The Association of Depressed Affect and Stroke in Institutionalized Canadians

Quetiapine and Neuroleptic Malignant Syndrome

Review Paper

Are Leptin and Cytokines Involved in Body Weight Gain During Treatment With Antipsychotic Drugs?

Trino Baptista, MD, PhD1, Serge Beaulieu, MD, PhD, FRCPC2

 

Objective: To critically review published literature on the causal association between leptin, cytokines, and excessive body weight gain (BWG) induced by antipsychotic drugs (APs).

Method:We completed a Medline search using the words leptin, cytokines, antipsychotic drugs, neuroleptics, psychotropic drugs, weight gain, and obesity. We also included our empirical research on this topic in the discussion. We examined the relation between leptin, cytokines (mainly tumour necrosis factor alpha [TNF-a ] and its soluble receptors), and AP- induced BWG, using the biological sciences’ current theories of causality.

Results: In the general field of weight regulation, there is scarce experimental evidence that leptin or TNF-a by themselves can induce obesity. Serum levels of leptin and TNF-a rather increase simultaneously as BWG occurs. This has also been reported during AP- induced BWG, with the equivocal exception of a study with clozapine. Some researchers have suggested that the absence of the expected correlation between leptin and body mass index (BMI ) or serum insulin levels, and the lack of sex-related differences in leptin levels in AP- treated patients, may point to a causal relation. This contention requires more experimental support. In addition, future clinical studies must carefully control for sex and BMI.

Conclusions: No conclusive evidence has been provided that leptin or TNF-a may induce obesity either in drug-free subjects or in AP-treated patients. In most cases, the elevated serum levels of these hormones appear to be a consequence rather than a cause of obesity. That does not mean that such an elevation is innocuous, since it may impair blood pressure and also carbohydrate and lipid metabolism regulation. Hence, all efforts should be made to prevent or attenuate BWG during treatment with APs.

Can J Psychiatry 2002;47:742–749)

Click here for author affiliations.

Click here for research funding and support.


Clinical Implications

  • Elevated serum levels of leptin and TNF-a are physiologically expected in antipsychotic (AP)-treated patients who gain body weight. Most evidence suggests that such an elevation is a consequence and not a cause of excessive body weight gain (BWG).

  • When high serum leptin levels are observed in AP-treated subjects with normal or low body mass index, it may be an important indicator of metabolic dysfunction, such as hyperinsulinemia and insulin resistance.

  • Since leptin and TNF-" are involved in the development and maintenance of myocardial infarction, hypertension, and insulin resistance, excessive BWG during AP treatment must be prevented or lessened.

Limitations

  • The proposal that leptin and cytokines may induce excessive BWG during AP treatment has not received unequivocal experimental support.

  • Clinical studies reporting anomalies in the expected correlation between leptin and relevant physiological variables or in the time-course of leptin or TNF-a elevation have important methodological limitations that preclude definitive conclusions.


Key Words
: antipsychotic drugs, cytokines, insulin, leptin, obesity, weight regulation

Résumé : La leptine et les cytokines participent-elles à la prise de poids durant le traitement aux antipsychotiques?

Excessive body weight gain (BWG) induced by antipsychotic drugs (APs) was reported soon after the introduction of chlorpromazine in psychiatry (1). However, interest in this problem increased after 1990 because of the strong propensity of some new atypical agents to induce BWG (2–4). Multiple mechanisms are probably involved in AP-induced BWG, and most research has focused on AP effects on brain histamine, serotonin, dopamine, and central and peripheral acetylcholine, as well as on the metabolic-endocrine effects of hyperprolactinemia (1,5).

Pollmächer and others (6) and Melkerson and others (7,8), have suggested a relation between AP-induced BWG and cytokines (mainly tumour necrosis factor alpha [TNF-a ]) and leptin. Authorities in the field now frequently mention this relation (4,9), and the implicit assumption is that leptin or TNF-a  may cause excessive BWG.

In this paper, we review the evidence relating leptin and TNF-a  to AP-induced BWG. We first describe the main findings on leptin and TNF-a  activity in cases of primary obesity. Second, we examine the studies that associate leptin and TNF-a  to AP-induced obesity. Our discussion is based on the current theories of causality in chronic diseases.

Leptin, TNF-a , and Primary Obesity

Leptin is a protein synthesized in the adipose tissue and, in minor proportions, in the placenta, stomach, and muscles (10). A few people and rodents lack leptin receptors in key tissues or display very low leptin production, along with severe obesity and diverse endocrine-metabolic abnormalities (11,12). Administration of the peptide to obese rodents lacking leptin decreases body weight (BW) and restores fertility (13). Leptin administration also decreases BW in obese or nonobese mice and rats (14,15) and in people with obesity not related to a leptin deficiency (16). In most humans and rodents, leptin serum levels correlate positively with body mass index (BMI: weight [kg] / height [m2]), with percentage of body fat, and with basal serum insulin levels (17,18). As an example, subjects with obesity or anorexia nervosa (AN) display higher and lower serum leptin levels, respectively, than do people with a normal weight. Importantly, these high or low leptin levels tend to normalize when an adequate BW is reached (19). Leptin levels are also higher in women than in men, even after correction for BMI (20).

Leptin is believed to be a messenger from the adipose tissue that signals the brain about the extent of body fat through a negative feedback regulatory mechanism. In turn, the nervous and endocrine systems should trigger a cascade of reactions to correct the increment or decrement in adipose tissue (11,12). However, an immediate question arises in relation to this model: Why don’t the increased leptin levels in obese patients correct excessive BW? It has been proposed that obesity is accompanied by a “leptin resistance” (10), a concept analogous to the insulin resistance observed in patients with diabetes and obesity. Such leptin resistance may be related to a decreased transport of the peptide through the blood–brain barrier and to postreceptor abnormalities (10).

TNF-a  is a protein of the cytokine family. It is mainly synthesized by adypocites and macrofages, but there is also local synthesis in the brain. It plays a prominent role in the mechanisms of tissue growth, inflammation, and immunity (6,21), and it is also involved in BW regulation. Intracerebral or systemic injections of TNF-a  decreased food intake and BW in rodents (22). In addition, severe BW loss and anorexia were observed in mice transfected with the human TNF-a  gene (23). In the adypocite, TNF-a  stimulates thermogenesis and lipolysis and decreases lipogenesis. Thus, it collectively decreases body fat and protein mass (21). In the cachectic states accompanying diverse diseases, TNF-a  is massively synthesized in the macrophages and is one of the main factors mediating the severe anorexia observed in these conditions. Interestingly, high circulating TNF-a  levels are found in obese subjects and correlate positively with the BMI and insulin and leptin levels (24). Converging evidence demonstrates that TNF-a  impairs insulin sensitivity and is a critical factor in the insulin resistance and diabetes mellitus associated with obesity (25).

Argiles and others developed a model for TNF-a  in BW regulation that resembles in some ways that of leptin (21). According to these authors, TNF-a  functions in healthy subjects as an adipostat and assists the brain in preventing excessive fluctuations in BW. Hence, during cachexia, the activity of TNF-a  is abnormally increased, whereas in obesity its action may be impaired (21).

Data obtained in some animal experiments suggest that TNF-a  may promote BWG (26,27), since nonobese male mice with a targeted disruption of this cytokine gene (TNF-a -/-) displayed less weight than their intact control littermates (TNF-a +/+) (27). In addition, when the 2 groups of animals were exposed to a high-fat diet that induces obesity, the fat pads in the TNF-a +/+ group weighed significantly more than in the TNF-a -/- group. As well, the BWG was nonsignificantly higher in the TNF-a +/+ group (26). However, using another model of obesity in mice (that is, the obese–obese model) and targeted mutations in 2 receptors for TNF-a , these authors found no difference in BWG and body composition between the obese mice with, or without, the receptor mutation (26). In a third model of obesity (induced by gold-thioglucose, which causes chemical ablation of the ventromedial hypothalamus and induces hyperphagic obesity), a similar degree of obesity was obtained in TNF-a +/+ and TNF-a-/- subjects (27). As a whole, these results show that TNF-a  is not necessary to observe obesity in mice, even though the cytokine modulates BW in nonobese mice.

Collectively, these data suggest that leptin and TNF-a  are hormones normally involved in physiological mechanisms regulating BW. However, once obesity is established, both hormones display deleterious effects on glucose homeostasis, blood pressure, and immunity.

Regarding the relation between leptin and the pathological regulation of BW, investigators are particularly attentive in describing subjects with abnormal or atypical correlations between leptin and the physiological variables that are relevant for BW regulation. It is thus of considerable scientific interest to find people in whom serum leptin levels do not correlate positively with BMI, with percentage of body fat, and with basal insulin levels or in whom changes in BW do not induce the expected changes in leptin levels. For example, subjects with hyperthyroidism or bulimia display lower leptin levels than would be expected for their BMI (28,29).

The initial conceptualization of the role of leptin in human physiology has evolved. It is now acknowledged that the peptide may be involved in numerous regulatory systems close or distal to signalling the body-fat size, such as the systems regulating nutrient availability, reproduction, hematopoiesis, the immune system, and the function of the adrenal and thyroid axis, among others (10). Initially, it also seemed implicit that the elevated leptin levels observed in cases of obesity were innocuous. This assumption has also been challenged, and converging evidence points to a role for leptin in the development of myocardial infarction (30), hypertension (31), insulin resistance (10), and prostatic cancer (32).


1 | 2 | 3 | 4


CJP Archives in English | Archives RCP en français
Supplements and Position Paper Inserts |
Lignes directrices cliniques, énoncés de principe et communiqués
Author Index to 2001 | Index RCP des auteurs 2001
Subject Index to 2001 | Index RCP des sujets 2001
Information for Contributors | Information à l'intention des auteurs
Style Notes for Contributors
Subscription Rates | Prix d'abonnements
Advertising Rates | Tarifs publicitaires
CPA Home | Page d'accueil